When it comes to golf irons, Mizuno has long been a leading brand in creating some of the most beautiful and high-performing clubs on the market. Among their offerings are the Mizuno MP-5 and MP-18, two classic iron sets that have been highly praised by golfers around the world. In this article, we’ll compare the key features of the Mizuno MP-5 and MP-18 to help you make an informed decision on which set is the best fit for your game.
Design and Appearance: The Mizuno MP-5 and MP-18 both feature a traditional, clean look that appeals to better players who appreciate the aesthetics of a classic forged iron. The MP-5 has a slightly larger head size and a thicker top line than the MP-18, which may inspire confidence in some golfers, especially those who prefer a more modern appearance. The MP-18, on the other hand, has a more compact and classic look that is highly sought after by purists.
Forging Process and Feel: Both the MP-5 and MP-18 are forged from 1025E Pure Select mild carbon steel, which is known for providing a soft, buttery feel at impact. This forging process results in a tight grain structure, which contributes to the excellent feedback and feel that Mizuno irons are known for. While both models deliver exceptional feel, some golfers may find the more compact MP-18 to be slightly more responsive due to its smaller clubhead.
Performance and Playability: The Mizuno MP-5 features a Channel Back design, which combines the playability of a muscle back with the forgiveness of a cavity back iron. This unique design allows for a thinner top line and more mass behind the sweet spot, resulting in a higher launch and more consistent ball flight. In contrast, the MP-18 is a true muscle back iron, offering a more penetrating ball flight and increased workability for skilled golfers.
The MP-5 is designed to be more forgiving than the MP-18, making it a better option for players who require a bit more assistance on off-center hits. The MP-18, being a pure muscle back design, is more suited to highly skilled golfers who prioritize shot-shaping capabilities and don’t mind sacrificing some forgiveness.
Shaft Options: Both the MP-5 and MP-18 come with a wide range of shaft options to cater to different swing types and preferences. Some of the most popular shaft options for these models include the True Temper Dynamic Gold, Project X, and Nippon Modus3 series. Custom shaft options are also available, ensuring that golfers can find the perfect combination to optimize their performance.
Customization and Adjustability: Mizuno offers a variety of customization options for both the MP-5 and MP-18 irons. Golfers can choose from various grip sizes, grip types, and even adjust the lie angle and loft of the clubs to match their unique swing dynamics. Additionally, both models are compatible with Mizuno’s Swing DNA system, which helps determine the optimal shaft, clubhead, and set makeup for each individual golfer. This level of customization ensures that you can fine-tune your set to match your specific needs and preferences, ultimately enhancing your performance on the course.
Price and Value: When comparing the Mizuno MP-5 and MP-18, it’s important to consider the price and value of each set. Both models are premium forged irons, and as such, they come with a relatively high price tag. However, the quality and performance of Mizuno irons make them a worthwhile investment for serious golfers. While the MP-5 may be slightly more affordable than the MP-18, the difference in price is typically not significant enough to be the deciding factor between the two models. Instead, golfers should focus on the performance characteristics and personal preferences that best align with their game.
Longevity and Durability: Mizuno is known for producing high-quality, durable golf clubs, and the MP-5 and MP-18 are no exceptions. Both models feature Grain Flow Forging, a process that enhances the strength and durability of the clubs, ensuring they maintain their performance over time. With proper care and maintenance, both the MP-5 and MP-18 iron sets should provide golfers with many years of enjoyable play.
Golfers Who Have Played These Models: It’s always helpful to know which professional golfers have played or are currently playing with the models you are considering. Both the MP-5 and MP-18 have been in the bags of several professional golfers, showcasing their performance and playability at the highest level. Some of the notable players who have used these models include Luke Donald, Chris Wood, and Oliver Fisher. These professionals’ success with Mizuno irons is a testament to the quality and performance of both the MP-5 and MP-18.
Deeper grooves, thicker face, Grain Flow Forged process
Deeper grooves, thicker face, Grain Flow Forged process
Smaller head, minimal offset, narrow sole
Smaller head, minimal offset, narrow sole, thin top
Solid, crisp, and soft at impact
Soft, consistent, and pleasing sound
Shaft Options Comparison
KBS Tour, Dynamic Gold AMT, Project X LZ
KBS Tour, Dynamic Gold, Project X, Project X LZ, Nippon Modus
The decision between the Mizuno MP-5 and MP-18 ultimately comes down to your skill level, personal preferences, and desired performance characteristics. If you are looking for a more forgiving iron with a slightly larger clubhead and a higher launch, the MP-5 may be the better choice. However, if you are a highly skilled golfer seeking maximum workability and a more penetrating ball flight in a classic, compact design, the MP-18 may be the ideal option. In either case, you’ll be investing in a high-quality, classic forged iron set that is sure to elevate your game.
Ray Barnes, our Senior Staff Writer and a Golf Analyst with a PhD in Sports Analytics, is a beacon of insight in the golfing world. With a deep understanding of the sport's nuances, statistical analysis, and a talent for demystifying complexities, he provides in-depth analysis and captivating narratives that engage golf enthusiasts worldwide.