When it comes to choosing the perfect set of irons for your golf game, the options can seem overwhelming. Two of the most popular and highly regarded forged blade irons in the market are the Srixon Z965 and the Mizuno MP 18. Both offer exceptional feel, control, and precision, but how do they compare head-to-head? In this article, we will delve into the similarities and differences between these two stellar iron sets, helping you decide which one is the best fit for your game.
Aesthetics and Design
Srixon Z965: The Srixon Z965 irons are designed with a compact and traditional shape that appeals to better players. They feature a classic, thin topline and minimal offset, giving them a clean, uncluttered appearance at address. The chrome finish adds a touch of elegance, making them an attractive option for golfers who appreciate a timeless look.
Mizuno MP 18: Mizuno’s MP 18 irons also boast a traditional blade design, with a slightly thinner topline and minimal offset. The satin finish offers a slightly more muted appearance compared to the chrome finish on the Z965 irons. Both irons have a similar compact shape, but the MP 18’s slightly more rounded leading edge may appeal to some golfers.
Feel and Feedback
Srixon Z965: The Z965 irons are constructed using Srixon’s 1020 Carbon Steel, which is known for providing excellent feel and feedback. Golfers can expect a soft, yet solid feel at impact, allowing them to easily discern mishits and make necessary adjustments.
Mizuno MP 18: Mizuno’s renowned Grain Flow Forging process is used to create the MP 18 irons, resulting in exceptional feel and feedback. Made from 1025E Pure Select Mild Carbon Steel, these irons offer a buttery soft feel that many golfers find unmatched. The MP 18 irons might have a slight edge in this department.
Performance and Forgiveness
Srixon Z965: While the Z965 irons are designed for skilled players, they offer a touch more forgiveness than a traditional blade. This can be attributed to the V.T. Sole design, which improves turf interaction and helps maintain clubhead speed. The Z965 irons also have a slightly lower center of gravity, which can help generate a higher launch and more consistent ball flight.
Mizuno MP 18: The MP 18 irons are less forgiving than the Z965 irons, catering to players with a higher degree of skill and ball-striking ability. The MP 18 irons are known for their precise shot-shaping capabilities, providing golfers with unparalleled control over their ball flight.
Customization and Shaft Options
Srixon Z965: Srixon offers a variety of shaft options for the Z965 irons, catering to golfers with different swing speeds and preferences. Some popular options include the Nippon Modus3 Tour 120, Dynamic Gold, and Project X shafts. These shafts are available in various flexes, ensuring the perfect fit for your swing. Additionally, Srixon offers custom fitting services, allowing golfers to fine-tune their club specifications, such as lie angle and length, for optimal performance.
Mizuno MP 18: Mizuno is known for their extensive shaft selection and custom fitting services. The MP 18 irons can be paired with various shaft options, including the KBS Tour, Project X, and Nippon Modus3 Tour 120, among others. Mizuno’s Shaft Optimizer system aids in finding the ideal shaft for each golfer, taking into account factors like swing speed, tempo, and release point. Customization options such as lie angle, length, and grip size are also available to ensure a perfect fit.
Workability and Spin Control
Srixon Z965: The Z965 irons are designed to provide golfers with excellent workability and control over their shots. The compact head and thin topline encourage shot-shaping, allowing skilled players to hit various types of shots with ease. The V.T. Sole design also contributes to improved spin control, giving golfers the ability to manipulate their ball flight as needed.
Mizuno MP 18: The MP 18 irons are known for their precise shot-shaping capabilities and exceptional spin control. The traditional blade design and compact head make it easy for skilled players to maneuver the clubface and produce desired shot shapes. The MP 18’s design and construction allow golfers to generate optimal spin rates, providing control over the trajectory and stopping power of their shots.
Price and Value
Srixon Z965: The Srixon Z965 irons are typically priced slightly lower than the Mizuno MP 18 irons, offering great value for the performance and quality they deliver. The Z965 irons are an excellent choice for golfers seeking a combination of feel, workability, and a touch of forgiveness in a classic blade design.
Mizuno MP 18: While the Mizuno MP 18 irons tend to be priced higher, they still offer excellent value for the premium feel and performance they deliver. Golfers who prioritize buttery soft feel and precision shot-shaping capabilities may find the MP 18 irons to be worth the investment.
Design Comparison
| Feature | Srixon Z965 | Mizuno MP 18 | Winner | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Blade Length | Shorter | Longer | Srixon Z965 | Better for precision shots |
| Offset | Minimal | Minimal | Tie | Both have minimal offset |
| Topline | Thinner | Thicker | Srixon Z965 | Sleeker appearance |
| Sole Width | Narrower | Wider | Srixon Z965 | Better for turf interaction |
| Back Design | Simpler | More intricate | Mizuno MP 18 | More appealing to some players |
Material Comparison
| Feature | Srixon Z965 | Mizuno MP 18 | Winner | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Head Material | Forged Carbon Steel | Forged Carbon Steel | Tie | Same material used |
| Shaft Material | Steel | Steel | Tie | Same material used |
| Grip Material | Rubber | Rubber | Tie | Same material used |
| Finish | Satin | Satin | Tie | Same finish used |
| Loft Material | Steel | Steel | Tie | Same material used |
Performance Comparison
| Feature | Srixon Z965 | Mizuno MP 18 | Winner | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Forgiveness | Less | More | Mizuno MP 18 | Better for less skilled players |
| Workability | More | Less | Srixon Z965 | Better for skilled players |
| Distance | Similar | Similar | Tie | Same distance potential |
| Trajectory | Lower | Higher | Srixon Z965 | Better for windy conditions |
| Spin | More | Less | Srixon Z965 | Better for controlling the ball |
Set Makeup Comparison
| Feature | Srixon Z965 | Mizuno MP 18 | Winner | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Iron Set | 3-PW | 4-PW | Srixon Z965 | More iron options |
| Wedge Set | Available, 52°-60° | Available, 50°-62° | Mizuno MP 18 | More wedge options |
| Left-Handed | Yes | Yes | Tie | Both offer left-handed sets |
| Custom Fit | Available | Available | Tie | Both offer custom fitting |
| Combo Set | Available | Available | Tie | Both offer combo sets |
Price Comparison
| Feature | Srixon Z965 | Mizuno MP 18 | Winner | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MSRP (per iron) | $174.99 | $149.99 | Mizuno MP 18 | Lower price point |
| Street Price | $139.99 | $124.99 | Mizuno MP 18 | Lower street price |
| Value | Good | Very Good | Mizuno MP 18 | Better value for money |
| Availability | Widely Available | Widely Available | Tie | Both are widely available |
| Discounts | Occasionally Available | Occasionally Available | Tie | Both have occasional discounts available |
Player Comparison
| Feature | Srixon Z965 | Mizuno MP 18 | Winner | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Handicap Range | Low-Mid | Mid-High | Srixon Z965 | Better for low to mid handicappers |
| Swing Speed | Fast | Moderate | Srixon Z965 | Better for faster swing speeds |
| Ball Flight | Lower | Higher | Srixon Z965 | Better for players who prefer a lower ball flight |
| Shot Shaping | More | Less | Srixon Z965 | Better for players who like to shape shots |
| Feel and Feedback | Softer | Crisp | Tie | Depends on player preference |
Set Configuration Comparison
| Feature | Srixon Z965 | Mizuno MP 18 | Winner | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Length of Irons | Standard | Standard | Tie | Same standard length |
| Grip Size | Customizable | Customizable | Tie | Both offer customizable grip size |
| Loft Options | Customizable | Customizable | Tie | Both offer customizable loft options |
| Iron Covers | Available | Not Available | Srixon Z965 | Iron covers can help protect clubs and improve longevity |
| Club Bag | Not Included | Not Included | Tie | Neither includes a club bag |
Warranty Comparison
| Feature | Srixon Z965 | Mizuno MP 18 | Winner | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Warranty | 2 years | 1 year | Srixon Z965 | Longer warranty period |
| Return Policy | 30-day Satisfaction | 30-day Satisfaction | Tie | Both offer a 30-day return policy |
Brand Comparison
| Feature | Srixon Z965 | Mizuno MP 18 | Winner | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Company History | Established in 1930 | Established in 1916 | Mizuno MP 18 | Longer company history |
| Tour Players | Hideki Matsuyama, Keegan Bradley, Graeme McDowell | Brooks Koepka, Paul Casey, Keith Mitchell | Tie | Both have |
Shaft Options Comparison
| Feature | Srixon Z965 | Mizuno MP 18 | Winner | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shaft Options | Limited | Limited | Tie | Both have limited shaft options |
| Shaft Flex | Regular, Stiff, X-Stiff | Regular, Stiff | Srixon Z965 | More flex options available |
| Shaft Material | Steel | Steel | Tie | Same material used |
| Shaft Weight | 120g | 120g | Tie | Same weight |
| Shaft Length | Standard | Standard | Tie | Same standard length |
Appearance Comparison
| Feature | Srixon Z965 | Mizuno MP 18 | Winner | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Design | Classic | Classic | Tie | Both have classic design |
| Finish | Satin | Satin | Tie | Same finish used |
| Branding | Minimal | Minimal | Tie | Both have minimal branding |
| Clubhead Size | Medium | Medium | Tie | Same clubhead size |
| Alignment Aids | Minimal | Minimal | Tie | Both have minimal alignment aids |
Launch Comparison
| Feature | Srixon Z965 | Mizuno MP 18 | Winner | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Launch | Lower | Higher | Srixon Z965 | Better for players who want a lower ball flight |
| Center of Gravity | Rearward | Centered | Srixon Z965 | Better for more skilled players |
| Sweet Spot Size | Smaller | Larger | Mizuno MP 18 | Better for less skilled players |
| Offset | Minimal | Minimal | Tie | Both have minimal offset |
| Face Design | Traditional | Traditional | Tie | Both have traditional face designs |
Conclusion
Both the Srixon Z965 and Mizuno MP 18 irons are exceptional options for low-handicap golfers seeking a classic blade design with superior feel and control. The Z965 irons offer a touch more forgiveness, while the MP 18 irons may have a slight edge in terms of feel. Ultimately, the decision between these two fantastic iron sets will come down to personal preference, feel, and the specific needs of your game. It is highly recommended to test both sets out on the range or course to determine which set is the perfect match for you.
